The Government of Newfoundland and Labrador regularly tests public drinking water supplies to ensure the absence of any microbiological, physical or chemical contaminants. Private water supplies, including wells however, fall outside the mandate of these testing regimes and thus monitoring becomes the sole responsibility of the individual well owner. There are over 40,000 wells in Newfoundland and Labrador servicing approximately one fifth of the total population. Limited information on private well water quality is available, especially of physical and chemical contaminants. A scan of provincial government water quality reports of public wells was performed to create a proxy model of the potential risk of private well contamination. Our results show potential problems with toxic levels of arsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, lead, mercury and selenium. Lead and arsenic pose the greatest risk with 13% and 10% of public wells having shown contamination at least once. Our model finds 8,544 people at risk for exposure to toxic levels of arsenic, 11,232 people at risk of exposure to toxic levels of lead, and 3,840 people at risk for exposure to the remaining contaminants from drinking water from private wells. In total, this model shows 5% of the province’s population at risk of exposure to toxic drinking water contaminants. A review of the literature was conducted to assess the health risks from each of these individual contaminants. Health risks on account of chronic exposure to these seven contaminants include cancer, cardiovascular disease, kidney damage, diabetes, as well as neurological and developmental conditions, among others.